Top Cast
Synopsis
In a quiet Irish setting, two boys — Fiachra and the enigmatic And — navigate the unspoken end of their friendship. When one finally voices the need to separate, the moment unfolds against a subtle fantasy backdrop that blurs the line between memory, metaphor, and something stranger.
With minimal dialogue and a runtime under 15 minutes, the film relies on gesture and atmosphere to convey a grief that feels both intimate and oddly universal.
And: A Micro-Budget Meditation on Grief That Struggles to Breathe
And, the 12-minute Irish short from writer-director James O'Donovan, arrives with a tagline — "Grief is just love persevering" — that feels lifted from a more ambitious project. In just a dozen minutes, the film attempts to blend fantasy allegory with the quiet dissolution of a childhood friendship, but the runtime proves its tightest constraint. O'Donovan, who also stars as the titular And opposite Tadhg Sweeney's Fiachra, directs with a deliberate stillness that occasionally reads as hesitation rather than restraint. The fantasy elements, hinted at in the genre tags, manifest more as atmospheric suggestion than realized world-building; a single recurring visual motif stands in for a deeper metaphysical framework that never fully materializes.
Performances Carry What the Script Leaves Unsaid
Sweeney and O'Donovan share a lived-in chemistry that suggests history without exposition — a crucial asset when the script offers so little of it. Their dialogue feels improvised in the best way: fragmented, overlapping, charged with the specific awkwardness of two people who know each other too well to pretend. O'Donovan's performance as And is quieter, more internalized; Sweeney carries the louder grief. But the film's central conceit — that one boy admits they need to part ways — arrives without the emotional architecture to support it. We're told a friendship is ending, but we're never shown why it mattered. The fantasy layer, presumably meant to externalize that internal rupture, remains too opaque to bridge the gap.
Who Might Connect With This Sliver of Cinema
Viewers drawn to micro-cinema's raw edges — those who value intention over execution — may find something resonant in And's refusal to explain itself. Festival programmers looking for Irish voices in experimental short-form work should take note. But general audiences seeking narrative clarity or emotional catharsis will likely leave frustrated. The film's ambition outpaces its capacity, and at 12 minutes, it doesn't earn the ambiguity it courts.
Pros
- Lived-in chemistry between the two leads
- Atmospheric visual restraint on a micro-budget
- Refuses to over-explain its central metaphor
- Distinct Irish voice in experimental short-form
- Tagline-worthy thematic ambition
Cons
- 12-minute runtime insufficient for emotional architecture
- Fantasy elements remain suggestive, not realized
- Friendship's history told, not shown — weakens the rupture
- Pacing reads as hesitation rather than deliberate stillness
- Ending ambiguity feels unearned, not resonant
Verdict
And shows a distinct directorial voice and strong lead chemistry, but its brevity starves the emotional stakes and fantasy conceit of necessary depth. Worth a watch for short-film enthusiasts; likely too elliptical for casual viewers.
Reader Rating
Be the first to rate this movie
Write a Review
Sign in to share what you thought — star ratings above need no account.
Frequently Asked
Is And worth watching?
If you appreciate micro-budget shorts that prioritize mood over plot, yes. General audiences may find it too opaque and brief to satisfy.
What is And about?
Two boys confront the end of their friendship, framed through a subtle fantasy lens that externalizes grief as something tangible but undefined.
Is And suitable for kids?
No official certification exists, but the themes of grief and separation, plus the abstract fantasy tone, make it more appropriate for teens and adults.
Who directed And?
James O'Donovan wrote, directed, and stars as And in this Irish short film.
How long is And?
12 minutes — a concise runtime that both defines and limits the film's ambitions.
If you liked this, watch
Movie data provided by TMDB. This product uses the TMDB API but is not endorsed or certified by TMDB.


