Aave Proposes to Freeze $279 Million in osETH Collateral
Aave considers freezing $279 million in osETH collateral, sparking a challenge from StakeWise's founder. Key proposals and implications discussed.

Aave is facing a critical decision regarding the management of osETH, the staking token from StakeWise. On November 11, 2026, StakeWise founder Dmitri initiated a forum post asking Aave governance to vote separately on freezing osETH. This request comes as a challenge to a broader collateral overhaul proposal put forth by the risk advisory firm, LlamaRisk, just a day earlier.
The proposed changes by LlamaRisk aim to mitigate risks tied to the shared borrowing pools in Aave's V3 Core market. In the context of the proposal, LlamaRisk estimates that osETH represents approximately $279.4 million in collateral, which underpins around $256.6 million in Wrapped Ethereum (WETH) debt.
Background of the osETH Situation
The challenges around osETH stem from the operational dynamics of Aave’s lending architecture, particularly within its efforts to tighten risk parameters as the market landscape evolves. One key concern is the vulnerability that arises from pooled borrowing rates, which LlamaRisk argues exposes suppliers of WETH and stablecoins to increased risks. These risks are compounded by the fact that borrowers in these pools can exploit the differences in rates through strategies that involve overlapping borrowing and larger staking positions.
In defense of osETH, Dmitri has emphasized that StakeWise has not experienced hacks or validator issues since January 2021. This lack of adverse events is positioned as a positive indication of the stability of osETH and its underlying structure, which is designed to return borrowed ETH directly from validators.
The Proposal Details from LlamaRisk
LlamaRisk’s November 9 proposal to Aave governance encompasses the following critical points:
- Stop new osETH supply and borrowing against it while maintaining existing positions.
- Setting the borrowing limit for osETH in the ETH-correlated efficiency mode (E-Mode) to zero, meaning no new exposure can be generated.
- Borrowers will have the option to either repay their loans or swap into alternative collateral like wstETH, weETH, cbETH, or WETH that are already available in the same E-Mode.
Additionally, the advisory has recommended regular engagement with issuers to monitor the situation and provide monthly progress reports to ensure a decreasing trend in exposure. If those measures fail, LlamaRisk has suggested a potential increase in WETH base borrowing rates as a last resort, with increments capped at 1% in 0.5% steps possibly implemented on a monthly basis.
StakeWise's Counter Proposal
In the face of LlamaRisk's recommendations, StakeWise's Dmitri argues that a separate voting mechanism could allow governance to fairly evaluate StakeWise's position without precipitating immediate action that might not favor stakeholders. The essence of his call for a distinct vote is to buy time for StakeWise to refine its arguments and better address the specific lending risk criteria outlined by LlamaRisk.
This counter proposal highlights StakeWise's capabilities and its ambition to establish favorable terms for osETH stakeholders while maintaining the robustness of the lending landscape.
Borrowing and Collateral Dynamics
Data from LlamaRisk shows that on November 9, there were approximately 122,900 osETH deposited, which slightly decreased to 122,400 by November 11. This indicates a modest decline in osETH positions but still reflects substantial collateral backing for significant WETH debt. The concentration of debt is particularly notable, with the top ten positions representing nearly 66% of the attributed debt.
Under the E-Mode conditions, osETH has a loan-to-value (LTV) ratio of 93%, suggesting that borrowers can leverage their collateral effectively, leading to an estimated leverage ratio of around 14 times. This level of leverage amplifies the stakes involved for lenders and borrowers alike, as any changes in collateral dynamics could dramatically impact the borrowing environment.

Governance Implications and What Happens Next
The governance decision surrounding the osETH freeze will not only influence current borrowing practices but could also set a precedent for how Aave manages collateral risk in the future. If the governance votes in favor of Dmitri's proposal for a separate voting session, this could lead to a more nuanced discussion surrounding the practical implications of freezing osETH.
As the proposal stands, if the osETH freeze takes effect, users will retain the options to either repay their borrowing commitments or transition to other collateral types. Still, the absence of immediate forced liquidations is a favorable aspect for existing users as it allows for a structured exit strategy.
Key Takeaways
- Aave is considering a vote to freeze $279.4 million in osETH collateral.
- StakeWise argues for a separate governance vote to highlight its operational strength.
- LlamaRisk estimates over $256.6 million in WETH debt is currently backed by osETH collateral.
- Ten largest positions in osETH represent 66% of the attributed debt, reflecting high concentration risk.
- Potential last-resort measures could include WETH borrowing rate increases if exposure fails to diminish.
As discussions unfold on this significant governance decision, the outcome will ultimately influence Aave’s operational landscape and determine the future risks associated with collateral management on its platform.
Frequently Asked Questions
