November 15, 2026•4 min read

Harvey Smith on Honoring Immersive Sims While Innovating

Harvey Smith explores the delicate balance between honoring immersive sim traditions and pioneering new paths at Black Pony Immersive after Redfall's missteps.

Harvey Smith discussing immersive sim game development

Belief in Immersive Sims

Harvey Smith, co-director of Dishonored and co-founder of Black Pony Immersive, holds a deep appreciation for immersive simulation games. His early experiences as the quality assurance lead on System Shock alongside the creative minds who worked on Ultima Underworld solidified his dedication to the genre. Smith describes these pivotal months as a significant turning point, where he witnessed firsthand the passion and resolve that defined the industry pioneers.

Reflecting on his career, Smith recalls how his vision for Arkane Studios was shaped by a refusal to compromise on creative integrity. Despite industry pressure to engage in projects outside their expertise, Arkane remained steadfast, often turning down lucrative opportunities to focus on immersive sims. "By saying no enough times, Arkane defined itself as a team of consummate worldbuilders and architects of intricate levels that emphasize deep exploration," he explains.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

The Challenges of Redfall

The studio's recent game, Redfall, was a departure from Smith's established principles, ultimately leading to disappointment among fans and critics alike. Smith candidly acknowledges, "Redfall was a game that did not come together; we never should have been working on a games-as-a-service project." The co-op looter-shooter was met with mixed reviews, and performance issues exacerbated its challenges. Expectations were high, particularly as it was one of Xbox's first major hits at a $70 price point, contributing to the weight of scrutiny it faced.

Along with design missteps, the game's launch revealed significant performance challenges, such as frames dropping well below expectations. Smith and his team learned a vital lesson from these issues: returning to their roots in immersive simulation is essential for future projects.

Formation of Black Pony Immersive

With the closure of Arkane Austin, Smith and production director Ben Horne co-founded Black Pony Immersive, driven by a commitment to create games in the immersive sim genre. Smith emphasizes the importance of staying true to their passion in recent interviews, stating, "Getting back to what we do best is the number one priority for us here at Black Pony."

As a team, they seek to make games that resonate deeply with players, focusing on creativity and exploration. Horne's experience working on annual NBA games has provided him with a fresh perspective in conceiving compelling narratives for immersive titles. He and Smith consistently pursue projects that challenge them to dig deeper into meaning and gameplay.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Core Themes of Immersive Sims

ThemeDescription
Power DynamicsExploration of systems of power and their implications on individuals and society.
Player AgencyEmphasis on allowing players to make meaningful choices impacting the game world.
Narrative DepthIncorporating rich storytelling elements that enhance gameplay experience and emotional engagement.

Expected Features of the New Game

FeatureDescription
First-Person GameplayA focus on immersive first-person perspective with elements of stealth and shooting.
Creative ExplorationA player-driven approach that encourages discovery and experimentation within the game.
Narrative-DrivenDeep, atmospheric storytelling woven into gameplay to enrich the player's experience.
Concept sketches for Black Pony Immersive's debut title
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Innovation vs. Tradition

Throughout the industry, Smith has observed two schools of thought within the immersive sim community regarding innovation: one that adheres strictly to the foundational principles, while another embraces experimentation. He describes this duality as "the two wolves inside me: the desire to meet established expectations and the push to exceed them with new ideas." This tension between honoring the genre's history and pushing towards innovation remains a core element of Black Pony's vision.

Smith and his team believe that by integrating new narrative themes and gameplay mechanics, they can stretch familiar concepts into uncharted territories. This dedication to reinvention can be illustrated through their approach to gameplay mechanics in Dishonored, where they reimagined possession abilities allowing players to strategize their approach to levels by shifting the context of familiar actions.

Looking to the Future

As Black Pony Immersive prepares to unveil its debut title, there is considerable anticipation in the gaming community. Filled with echoes of past successes like Dishonored and Deus Ex, Smith's latest endeavor aims to channel their profound respect for the immersive sim genre while forging a new path. Through constant innovation woven into rich narratives and deep exploration, the hope is to engage players in a way that honors the legacy of immersive sims.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Key Takeaways

  • Harvey Smith champions immersive sims, emphasizing innovation and tradition.
  • The recent struggles with Redfall indicated the need to return to Arkane's roots.
  • Black Pony Immersive focuses on crafting games centered around player agency and narrative depth.
  • Smith identifies two conflicting schools of thought within the genre: innovation vs. adherence to tradition.
  • Upcoming projects are expected to combine systems of power exploration with engaging gameplay.

Conclusion

Exploring new directions while respecting the foundations of immersive simulation is a tightrope Smith walks, but his commitment to creativity and narrative depth offers hope for Black Pony Immersive's future endeavors. As the gaming community awaits more details on their next project, it is certain that Smith's journey will continue to inspire players and creators alike, further enriching the legacy of immersive sims.

Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement

Frequently Asked Questions

Harvey Smith is known for his significant contributions to immersive sims as co-director of titles like Dishonored and his recent work with Black Pony Immersive.
#Harvey Smith#immersive sims#game development#Arkane Studios#Redfall
Advertisement